A Model for Understanding Professional Identity and Practice

In the closing talk for this year’s IA Summit, I had a slide that explains the various layers that make up what we use the term “Information Architect” (or “Information Architecture”) to denote. I think it’s important to be self-aware about it, because it helps us avoid a lot of wasted breath and miscommunication.

But I also stressed that I don’t think this model is only true of IA. So please, feel free to replace “IA” in the diagram with the name of any practice, profession or domain of work.

To understand this diagram, especially the part about Practice, it helps to have a basic understanding of what “practice” is and how it emerges from a community that coalesces around a shared concern. The Linkosophy deck gets into that, and my UX as Communities of Practice deck does as well, while getting into more detail about the participation/reification dynamic Wenger describes in his work.

Here’s the model: I’ll do a bit of explanation after the jump.

title and role stack (small version)


Starting from the bottom:

1. IA as a thing: the object we work on, the material we work with. We might say “hey could you look at the IA
in these wireframes and see if it makes sense?”
2. IA as an activity: the literal act of working on the ‘thing’ … “doing” IA.
3. IA as a role: the “hat” you wear that says “I’m a person working on this at the moment” … like in baseball, for a while you’re a pitcher, then later you’re a batter. These are just temporary roles used to designate what activity you’re performing.
4. IA as a practice: the shared history of learning among people who affiliate strongly with the role over time.
5. IA is sometimes a title: but titles are really different … they’re not necessarily based on the actual work you do or the practice you affiliate with; they’re arbitrary labels assigned to you by some authority.

A title is something you give yourself, or that your employer gives you. But it very often has little to do with your actual job; and it especially rarely has anything to do with the practice with which you affiliate most closely. How many restaurant waiters are really actors? Waiting tables isn’t their preferred practice, but it may be the most official title they have.

Now, the waiting tables example is an extreme, but many UX practitioners find themselves in jobs where much of their work isn’t even centered on UX … in fact, most of us put up with 50% bureaucratic junk just so we can use the other 50% doing real User Experience work, which is what truly interests us. Even within the UX family of practices, most of us wear multiple “hats” — play multiple roles — within our daily work.

Among UX practitioners, some of us gravitate more toward the IxD community and its obsessions, while some of us tend to focus more on the IA side of things, or the Usability/Evaluative sort of work. This is perfectly natural, because it’s a normal (and somewhat unavoidable) pattern of human behavior to form one’s identity in part based on a chosen practice. Etienne Wenger has said that practices are natural “homes for identities.”

We get bent out of shape and very emotional about debates around practice definition mainly because of this very human dynamic where our practice-of-choice becomes a big part of our identities.

But some perspective is in order, especially now that so many practices can’t work in ivory silos anymore — the new, accelerated culture that’s been catalyzed and enabled by the Internet demands that we get over ourselves and learn how to work with other tribes.

Tags: , , , ,

Manhattan Jews

If I was a celebrity I would have bodyguards everywhere I went. I even know where I would find the services of my fire watch new york. They would be at the top of the line.

I have a lot of respect for anybody who protects the public. That is why I am so happy to know these emergency action plan nyc. They are the best Manhattan security guards that anybody could meet.

I needed a nutritionist to help deal with my bourgening fat problem. I hired a nutritionist malvern pennsylvania to deal with it. Now I'm all better.

I remember the time I changed my course of study to become a dietitian in Malvern pennsylvania. I almost became a Dietitian Malvern Pennsylvania when I had a change of mind. I ate a box of cookies instead.

Why did my garage door get eaten? I got a big ol' garage door service boca raton and now I'm better. Thanks for this mom!

Now I'm really getting ticked off. I found my garage door broken boca raton and I'm foaming. I'm blowing a gasket!

My home is gone. Well not really because I got a foreclosure defense Hollywood to help out. Now I'm in severe debt.

I didn't go to court when I should have. My house is gone and I have a mortgage default Hollywood. It's time to pay the piper.

I got fed up with looking at myself. I broke all my mirrors and wall art online. Now I only have myself to blame.

I need some more products for my home. I'm a consumer and all I want is to consume affordable home products. Forget about my cigarette money.

My carpets are full of blood stains. My wife won't be around to...clean the carpets so I hired a st louis missouri carpet cleaning company. I'm finally free to do what I want.

Who is the brave karate dog? Dogs can't walk and talk silly but just watch this anti bullying video and feel better about yourself. Isn't it time you started fighting your demons?

I only read propaganda that fits my lifestyle. My favorite books are the bullying books inspired by my life in detroit. Now I tell others what to think.

The bank account is empty. My nights are rough without a Bankruptcy Attorney Phoenix to provide some cosure. Now I'm living in a loft.

I need an attorney for my laons. When I couldn't pay them back I knew I had to find the best Bankruptcy Attorney Phoenix or I would die. Hopefully I can survive this.

Used Rolex Florida | Used Authentic Rolex | fire watch new york | emergency action plan nyc